Wednesday, November 05, 2003

Becoming a "Tolkien Scholar"
I've been having a few conversations (email and otherwise) about how one becomes a Tolkien scholar, so I thought I would blog about it, particularly because the whole topic raises issues of credentialing, etc., that I think we in academia should be addressing right now.

It is an interesting fact that a great many of the very best contemporary Tolkien scholars are not professors: Wayne Hammond and Christina Scull, Doug Anderson, David Bratman, Richard West, Carl Hostetter... many of these scholars have academic affiliations (at libraries, etc.), but they aren't professors of English or history or cultural studies. Yet they are among the best.

One big reason for this phenomenon is that Tolkien scholarship has not been an academically respected field. The only person I know who did a dissertation on Tolkien and has an academic position (and tenure) is Verlyn Flieger (also one of the very, very best Tolkien scholars ever). So, with academia rejecting Tolkien scholarship for whatever reason, the field was open for independent scholars to make a mark.

[Aside: this is not to say that indep. scholars can't make a mark in field where there is a strong academic presence, just that it is, I think, much harder. Academics have huge advantages of time and access over scholars who also have to have a real job to pay the bills. That so many indep. scholars have contributed to so many fields is testament both to the problems of academia and the brilliance of people who take the indep. route].

I am, I think, less biased against indep. scholars than many of my English colleagues because Anglo-Saxon studies has a long tradition of great independent scholars. Numismatics, place-names and local history are well-populated by 'amateurs' whom the 'experts' respect as knowing as much or more than the experts. This is a good thing.

So, in answer to people who want to contribute to Tolkien scholarship but don't have a credential: Just Do It. Study medieval lit, WWI lit, Victorian and Edwardian lit, and, most importantly, Tolkien's works themselves. Write up your conclusions and send them to me at Tolkien Studies. I'll have them anonymously reviewed and, if the reviewers agree, I'll publish them. You'll have the opportunity to be taken seriously (and thus both admired and attacked) just like any other Tolkien scholar.

To add one more thing: I am a pretty big Tolkien geek. I have read the History of Middle-earth, all twelve volumes, more than twice. I've read the LotR over 40 times and the Silmarillion about 30 times. I've memorized a lot of the poetry. I understand the logic behind the alphabets. But I know for a fact that there are a lot of people out there who know a lot more about the internal elements of Middle-earth than I do. These people are enormous resources for Tolkien scholarship, and they should be encouraged and listened to, not mocked or derided. I think that my additional training in literary study, ancient languages and linguistics gives me the opportunity to add value and context to the analysis and discovery by people who work only within the materials of Middle-earth, but I don't ever pretend that I know more about Middle-earth than they do.

8 comments:

uiyui said...

I would gold für wow cultivate courage.buy wow gold “Nothing is so mild wow gold cheap and gentle as courage, nothing so cruel and pitiless as cowardice,” syas a wise author. We too often borrow trouble, and anticipate that may never appear.”wow gold kaufen The fear of ill exceeds the ill we fear.” Dangers will arise in any career, but presence of mind will often conquer the worst of them. Be prepared for any fate, and there is no harm to be freared. If I were a boy again, I would look on the cheerful side. life is very much like a mirror:sell wow gold if you smile upon it,maple mesos I smiles back upon you; but if you frown and look doubtful on it,cheap maplestory mesos you will get a similar look in return. Inner sunshine warms not only the heart of the owner,world of warcraft power leveling but of all that come in contact with it. “ who shuts love out ,in turn shall be shut out from love.” If I were a boy again, I would school myself to say no more often.billig wow gold I might cheap mesos write pages maple meso on the importance of learning very early in life to gain that point where a young boy can stand erect, and decline doing an unworthy act because it is unworthy.wow powerleveling If I were a boy again, I would demand of myself more courtesy towards my companions and friends,wow leveling and indeed towards strangers as well.Maple Story Account The smallest courtesies along the rough roads of life are wow powerleveln like the little birds that sing to us all winter long, and make that season of ice and snow more endurable. Finally,maple story powerleveling instead of trying hard to be happy,archlord online gold as if that were the sole purpose of life, I would , if I were a boy again, I would still try harder to make others happy.

game gold said...

At one time or another, I do not have the rf gold ; at the first time, I am not willing to buy rf online gold . But I do not wonder I buy the rf money , my friend thinks that I am ill. But when I have it, it carries the magic from such a group, such a link in the world, rf cp , it is the key bring you to this world. But buy cheap rf gold is the best desire that I make.

Without thinking I buy some runescape gold . I use some buy runescape and want to find a good group. We often buy rs gold together on Monday. As if it is a rule. I think it is the real friendship. runescape money is already become the essential thing in my life. So I will introduce my friends have the cheap rs gold , we can be consist of a group, it must be very interesting.

jislsnhd said...

I always heard something from my neighbor that he sometimes goes to the internet bar to play the game which will use him some maple mesos,he usually can win a lot of mesos,then he let his friends all have some cheap mesos,his friends thank him very much for introducing them the maplestory mesos,they usually maple story mesos together.
I am so happy to get some Metin2 gold and the Metin2 yang is given by my close friend who tells me that the Cheap metin2 yang is the basis to enter into the game. Therefore, I should Cheap metin2 gold with the spare money and I gain some Buy metin2 gold from other players.

陈凯燕 said...

Do you know 2moons dil? I like it.
My brother often goes to the internet bar to buy 2moons gold and play it.
After school, He likes playing games using these 2moon dil with his friend.
I do not like to play it. Because I think that it not only costs much money but also spend much time. One day, he give me many buy 2moons dil and play the game with me.
I came to the bar following him and found cheap 2moons gold was so cheap. After that, I also go to play game with him.

Do you know Asda Story gold? I like it.
My brother often goes to the internet bar to buy Asda Story money and play it.
After school, He likes playing games using these buy Asda Story Gold with his friend.
I do not like to play it. Because I think that it not only costs much money but also spend much time. One day, he give me manycheap Asda Story gold and play the game with me.

cheng said...

What do you know aoc gold. And do you want to know? You can get conan gold here. And welcome to view our website, here you can play games, and you will get age of conan gold to play game. I know cheap aoc gold, and it is very interesting. Do you want a try, come and view our website, and you will learn how to aoc money. Come and join with us. We are waiting for your coming.
What do you know FFXI Gil. And do you want to know? You can FFXI gold here. And welcome to our website, here you can play games, and you will get Final Fantasy XI gold to play game. I know buy FFXI Gil, and it is very interesting. I like playing online games. Do you want a try, come and view our website, and you will learn much about cheap Final Fantasy XI Gold. Come and join with us. We are waiting for your coming.

mei said...

Do you know latale online gold? I like it.
My brother often go to the internet bar to buy latale gold and play it.
After school, He likes playing games using these latale money with his friends.
I do not like to play it. Because I think that it not only costs much money but also spend much time. One day, he give me many buy latale online gold and play the game with me.
I came to the bar following him and found cheap latale gold was so cheap. After that, I also go to play game with him.

I am so happy to get some aion kina from my friends. They know I need aion online kina, they give me. So I always can get some aion gold from my friends. I buy aion kina with my spare money. It makes me happy that I can still earn some cheap aion kina.

筱娅 said...

Have you heared about 9Dragons which you need use 9Dragons gold to play, and you can also borrow 9 Dragons gold from other players? But you can buy 9 Dragons gold, or you will lose the choice if you do not have cheap 9Dragons gold. If you get 9Dragons money, you can continue this game.
Have you heared about a game which you need use Anarchy credits to play, and you can also borrow Anarchy Online credits from other players? But you can buy AO credits, or you will lose the choice if you do not have Anarchy online gold. If you get Anarchy gold, you can continue this game.

feilin said...

I like holic gold very much. Since I entered into this game, I learnt skills to earn holic money. Thanks to holic online gold let me know a lot of friends. It is my habit to buy holic online money, and I get some cheap holic gold from my friends and Internet.
I like hero gold very much because it is very useful. In fact at first sight I have fallen in love with hero online gold. So no matter how much I have spent to buy hero gold, I never regret. Because of hero online money, I meet a lot of friends. So I never hesitate to buy hero money.